An understatement if ever there was one!
Underestimating
the dangers of peak oil and climate change
The
threats of declining oil production and a changing climate are more
serious than we think, Cobb writes.
8
October, 2012
Many
people dismiss the risks associated with oil depletion and climate
change – even many who accept the two issues as problems. They
judge those risks to be small or at least manageable. Since no one
can know the future, we cannot be sure whether they are right or
wrong. But even if they are right, should we be so sanguine? As we
examine this question, keep in mind that we are talking about
probabilities and the level of risk, not absolute knowledge which
none of us can have about the future.
One
reason that so many people discount the risks of oil depletion and
climate change is that their experience tells them to do so. We've
had high oil prices and tight oil supplies before, and always new
supplies and declining prices followed. For many we are just in
another market cycle, and there's nothing to be worried about. And,
when it comes to climate change, well, we've had hot summers before
and even if the climate is warming a bit, we'll adapt.
Both
of these observations are subject to what's called the problem of
induction. In a nutshell, we believe that because a certain event has
reliably repeated itself in the past or because certain conditions
have prevailed for a long time, we can always expect more of the same
in the future. If that were true, there would come a point in our
lives when we would never be surprised. But as it turns out, humans
are continually surprised, which shows you that the problem of
induction lives on.
The
classic illustration is the statement: "All swans are white."
The statement may be based on thousands, even millions of
observations. But, this would not prove that it is true. This is
because we cannot possibly observe all swans for eternity. And, it
takes only one swan which is not white to prove the statement false.
As it turns out, Europeans only realized that this statement was
false when they landed in Australia and saw black swans.
So,
just because high oil prices in the past have eventually led to low
oil prices does not necessarily mean they will this time. Oil is a
finite resource. At some point it will never be plentiful again. Has
that point come? Is that even the question we should be asking? I'll
elaborate below.
When
it comes to climate, the globe's warming temperature is an
indisputable fact, something that even reluctant oil industry CEOs
now accept. So the question for them and for us is whether we can
adapt or whether we should try to stop the rise in global
temperatures.
Even
last summer's intense drought in the United States, dryness in the
growing regions of South America and Russia, and wildly wet weather
in Great Britain still seem not to have made climate change a
priority. Food prices may well exceed their all-time highs of 2008.
Yet, we humans are like the man plunging from a 100-story building
who, when asked how things are going as he passes a 50th-floor
window, replies: "Fine, so far."
This
oft-cited illustration shows in a humorous way that we humans are
frequently oblivious to dangers that are right in front of us, but
which for some reason we cannot immediately sense or comprehend. We
base our assessment of risk on the past (in this case the 50 floors
from the top traveled so far). The result is that we assign a
probability of harm that is too low.
But
even if the probability of severe peril from a future ongoing,
permanent decline in oil supplies or from climate change is actually
small, should we ignore that probability? Let me provide another
illustration which may be familiar to many. Let's say that you are
offered a free trip to your favorite vacation destination. You are
told that the plane arrives safely 95 percent of the time. The other
5 percent of the time it crashes. Pretty good odds, right? Of course,
not. You would never board such a plane. You would decline the flight
and gladly pay your own way on another safer flight, that is, if you
still wanted to go. […]
For
rest of article GO
HERE
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.