Saturday, 7 May 2016

Al-Nusra Front behind Aleppo refugee camp attack

Nothing of this from the Guardian that I can see.

Evidence hints Al-Nusra Front behind Aleppo refugee camp attack, no signs of airstrike - Russian MOD


6 May, 2016

Thursday's attack on an Aleppo refugee camp could have been carried out by Al-Nusra Front militants, Russia's Defense Ministry says. The damage pattern suggests rocket artillery use, and air control data show no sorties in the area at the time.

"Considering the fracture pattern, seen in the pictures and videos taken at the site, the camp could have been shelled, either intentionally or by mistake, by rocket artillery, which is in active use in the area by militants from the terror group Al-Nusra Front," Major-General Igor Konashenkov, Russian Defense Ministry spokesman, said on Friday.

He added that after analyzing photographs and video footage from the devastated camp available online, it became evident that "there are no airstrike shell craters or other signs of an airstrike."

The Russian Defense Ministry states there were no air sorties over the area of the refugee camp on the day of the attack or on the day prior to it.

"We have analyzed airspace objective control data for the area as of May 4 and 5, 2016. There were no flights of Russian or any other aircraft over the camp area," Konashenkov stressed.

"Since [Thursday] many international media outlets, citing the UK-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, have been reporting an airstrike that hit the refugee camp in Northern Idlib province, near the town of Sarmada.

I want to draw attention to the fact that the initial report oddly coincided with Thursday's concert of the Russian Mariinsky theatre musicians in Palmyra, conducted by Valery Gergiev.

The initial report itself cannot be found on the website of the Syrian Observatory, it's just not there. Only a post on Facebook without time or date of the report, which was surprisingly quickly found and broadly disseminated by a Reuters correspondent, who himself was at the time in neighboring Lebanon.

Notwithstanding all this, the report was quickly taken up by international mass media and even drew comments from officials from the UN, US and UK."

Konashenkov said there was no information to support the claims that the attack was carried out by Syrian President Bashar Assad's forces.

UK Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond was one of those who rushed to blame the bombing on the Syrian government.

The Assad regime’s contempt for efforts to restore the cessation of hostilities in Syria is clear for all to see,” Hammond said in an official statement on Thursday.

There is “no conclusive evidence” which can confirm that the damage inflicted to the refugee camp is the result of an airstrike, believes former UK army officer and security analyst Charles Shoebridge.

Judging by the video, there is actually “no signs of cratering,” which most probably means that no heavy weapons were used, he told RT. The camp suffered more extensively from “the impact of fire,” he said. Apart from that, “with an air strike you wouldn’t expect tent structures still to be standing,” Shoebridge noted.

Speaking of the timing of the attack, which occurred on the same day the Russian symphony orchestra was giving a performance in the recently liberated ancient city of Palmyra, Shoebridge suggested that it may have been carried out only to “distract attention from what Russia has achieved there [in Syria],” especially taking into account how quickly some of the Western media outlets jumped to the conclusion that President Assad or Moscow was behind the attack.

Meanwhile, the Syrian government has released an official communique rebuffing claims that the Syrian Army conducted airstrikes at the refugee camp near Sarmada, Sana news agency reported.

Sarmada is a town in Syria’s northwest near the Turkish border, and is said to be controlled by rebel groups opposed to President Bashar Assad. The makeshift camp which was attacked on Thursday is believed to have been temporary home to an estimated 2,000 people who had fled war zones. Some 30 people have reportedly been killed in the attack and dozens more injured.

Refugee camp bombed near Aleppo: Multiple casualties reported, blame game begins

6 May, 2016

The UN has condemned the bombing of a Syrian refugee camp in Sarmada, a city 30km from Aleppo, in which dozens of civilians, including women and children, were allegedly killed or injured. A video has emerged showing the aftermath of attack.

Sarmada is located in Syria’s northwestern Idlib province close to the Turkish border and is said to be controlled by rebel factions fighting the government of President Bashar Assad. The makeshift camp which was targeted is said to have been accommodating up to 2,000 people who fled war-torn areas seeking safety.

While no party has claimed responsibility for what reports have called an airstrike, White House spokesman Josh Earnest said US-led coalition warplanes were not on a mission in the stricken area, while stressing that “there is no justifiable excuse for carrying out an airstrike against innocent civilians who have already once fled their homes to escape violence.”

UN Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs and Emergency Relief Coordinator Stephen O’Brien condemned the attack in a statement, while calling for an “immediate, impartial and independent investigation into this deadly incident.”

© Abdalrhman Ismail

According to the reports cited by O’Brien, at least 30 people fell victim to the airstrikes that devastated two settlements, while over 80 people were injured. The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights had reported those numbers earlier.

If the deliberate nature of the attack is proven, the incident will “amount to a war crime,” the UN official added.

US State Department spokesman Mark Toner refused to immediately lay the blame for the attack on any party, including the Syrian armed forces, citing a lack of details concerning the incident. “We [US] don’t have eyes on the ground,” he stressed.

We’ve seen early claims that this was a regime strike, but we just want to be absolutely sure before we level blame at somebody,” he told journalists at a press briefing on Thursday.

A video allegedly depicting the deserted Kamounia camp after the airstrike was posted on YouTube by the Syria Civil Defense group, which describes itself as a non-political humanitarian organization. The footage shows firefighters attempting to stifle a blaze with debris strewn around the camp, while sheet-covered bodies were being carried to an ambulance.


According to the group’s estimates, more than 30 people lost their lives in the bombing.

While there is no conclusive information on the perpetrator of the attack, UK Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond immediately rushed to blame the bombing on the Syrian government.

“The Assad regime’s contempt for efforts to restore the cessation of hostilities in Syria is clear for all to see,” he said in astatement, while describing the reports pertaining to the attack as “horrifying.”

The attack comes just a day after at least 12 people were killed and 45 injured in suicide blasts in the Syrian city of Homs.

Moscow and Washington confirmed on Wednesday that they had brokered a 48-hour ceasefire in Aleppo, which has been the scene of heavy fighting recently. The deal came into force on May 3 and should have been observed until 12 am on May 6.

No comments:

Post a Comment